What 'Then Came You' Gets Right (and Skips) About Cancer Bucket Lists

On screen

"Then Came You" (2018) pairs Skye, a teen with cancer, with Calvin, an airport worker who's convinced he's dying of something himself. Skye has a bucket list. She recruits Calvin to help her finish it before her illness kills her. It's a comedy. But it follows a familiar shape: a young person with serious illness compresses a lifetime into an adventure countdown. Often a companion learns to live fully because of her. "The Fault in Our Stars" is the best-known example. The bucket-list-teen-cancer story is now a recognizable one.

That shape isn't invented. Making lists, setting goals, and choosing how to spend limited time are real things people facing serious illness do. There's genuine psychology behind it. But films smooth over what real teens with cancer actually experience.

The reality of coping

People facing a life-threatening diagnosis often want meaning and a sense of agency. A diagnosis can make people feel their body and future are no longer under their control. Deliberate action, like planning something to look forward to, helps restore that sense of choice. NCI notes that feeling overwhelmed often comes from a loss of control. It says engaging in meaningful activities helps people manage that feeling.

Cancer hits teens and young adults at a life stage built on identity, independence, and looking forward — first jobs, first relationships, plans for the future. NCI notes this age group faces distinct challenges: fertility concerns, loss of independence, and isolation from friends. A bucket list reclaims some of the forward motion that treatment takes away.

That part is real. What movies skip is the texture of treatment. Fatigue can make spontaneous trips impossible. There's nausea, immune limits on travel or crowds, care logistics and cost, and long stretches of hospital routine instead of adventure. Isolation, such as missing school and friends, is part of it too.

Why bucket lists aren't the only path

A bucket list is one coping style, not a requirement. Some people find comfort in forward planning. Others cope through routine, faith, family, advocating for other patients, or simply getting through appointments. Some don't make a list at all. NCI lists several coping strategies — counseling, support groups, everyday activity — because no single emotional response to a diagnosis is the right one.

It's worth naming what films unintentionally imply: that "good" illness coping looks adventurous and cinematic, and that patients who don't want that are missing something. The reality is different. Coping looks different for every person and every diagnosis. There's no wrong way to spend unexpected time.

What to keep in perspective

• Bucket lists reflect a real coping mechanism — regaining a sense of control and meaning — but they're a choice, not a requirement of "doing cancer right."
• Actual treatment for teens and young adults involves fatigue, disrupted routines, and logistics that adventure films rarely show.
• Coping styles vary widely; NCI's resources describe multiple approaches, from counseling to support groups to simply maintaining daily routines.

Sources

• Then Came You (2018), directed by Peter Hutchings, starring Maisie Williams and Asa Butterfield
• National Cancer Institute, "Feelings and Cancer" — https://www.cancer.gov/about-cancer/coping/feelings
• National Cancer Institute, "Adolescents and Young Adults with Cancer" — https://www.cancer.gov/types/aya

How this article was prepared

An AI-assisted editorial system helped prepare this page. No named medical reviewer has reviewed it unless one is listed.

Cancer Explained is published by the National Cancer Information Foundation. It is not medical advice and does not suggest a test or treatment.

See an error, old source, or unclear wording? Tell us.